
We’ve decided to throw a few extra posts in here, things that aren’t on The List but have nonetheless factored into our Twin Cities experience. This one will be written from Dave’s point of view, because while Lizzie loves music and likes this particular band just fine, it’s Dave – me – who flipped out about them. So: the Replacements.
I’d heard the name before, and I’d heard Paul Westerberg – I’d even heard his ridiculous “Dyslexic Heart” song from the so-nineties-it-hurts movie
Singles (you know it, your memory just did you a favor). But I’d barely heard the Replacements, and when we moved here, the lore was everywhere: the band once haunted the C.C. Club, Bob and Tommy’s mom is still a waitress at the Uptown, there’s a bench named after Bob over by Lake Of The Isles, the cover of
Let It Be was shot at 2215 Bryant, Bob died at an apartment across the street from Bryant-Lake Bowl. Also, they made some of the best music ever made.
At first I (very) snobbily chalked this reputation up to a city grasping for musical relevance. Prince? Of course. Soul Asylum? I remember them being huge, so why not. The Replacements?
Really? Then I bought
Pleased To Meet Me. (I started with that mid-career one because it had the only Replacements track I’d heard before – the sweet-as-candy “Can’t Hardly Wait”.) I was immediately addicted. The tinny 1987 production was a little jarring at first, but the amazing songs shone through: “Never Mind”, “Skyway”, the brilliant “Alex Chilton”. Who
were these guys?
Next came
Let It Be and
Tim (of those, I’m one of the few who prefer
Tim; I’ll spare you the argument, but head
here if you’re interested). Those two just about killed me. They also cemented for me why Midwesterners love them: they were also-rans, sometimes forgotten amid hype about the coasts. They were mascots, and though the aw-shucks look was mostly a put-on – they deliberately fucked up gigs lest anyone take them too seriously – it worked, and still does.
Local music fixture Jim Walsh wrote a very good oral history of the Replacements called
All Over But The Shouting, in which someone says the band’s attitude was a balance (or imbalance?) of “I Don’t Give a Fuck” and “I Give More of a Fuck Than Anyone Else on This Planet”. While that sounds like the insincerity of a New York hipster, in that description I hear what I love about Minneapolis: this city is awesome, but, uh, it’s not
that awesome, so don’t come here and tell everyone and blow it for the rest of us. It’s the drunken blow-off “Mr. Whirly” followed by the heart-stopping ballad “Within Your Reach” on the album
Hootenanny, a shrug followed by a bid for legitimacy.
But this kind of thing is written about the band and its city every day, and like the band itself, it is either pure bullshit or absolutely real, or maybe both. Likewise, I once interviewed Walsh about his book, and when I asked him for his favorite Replacements song, he laughed and said, “I don’t know. It changes all the time. It’s an impossible question, because A, I don’t really go into that kind of sports stuff about music, but, B – my favorite Replacements song is ‘Favorite Thing’.”
Dave’s favorite Replacements tracks on Sunday, May 17, 2009:
10 Shiftless When Idle
9 Color Me Impressed
8 Favorite Thing
7 Here Comes A Regular
6 Within My Reach
5 I Will Dare
4 Bastards Of Young
3 Can’t Hardly Wait (The
Tim Version)
2 Kiss Me On The Bus
1 Unsatisfied